British Shorthair vs Maine Coon

Verdict

Both cats are sturdy and sociable, but the Maine Coon asks for more space and grooming. The British Shorthair rates 2 for energy and 5 for apartment living, and tolerates quiet days alone. The Maine Coon is a large, very common cat of typically 8 to 18 lb with a thick coat that needs brushing a few times a week, and it scores 5 for children and other pets. Choose the British Shorthair for a calm cat in a small home and the Maine Coon for a larger, friendlier, busier one.

Choose the British Shorthair if

• You live in a small or quiet home, with apartment living at 5 against 3.
• You want a calm cat with energy at 2.
• You are out for part of the day, since independence is 4.
• You prefer a short coat that is easier to groom.

Choose the Maine Coon if

• You want a large, sociable cat and accept a bigger litter box and food bill.
• Your home has children or other pets, since it scores 5 for both.
• You will brush a thick coat a few times a week.
• You want a more playful cat, with play at 4 against 3.

Where they are alike

Both cats shed heavily, each at 4, and both are quiet, with voice at 2 or lower. Each lists hypertrophic cardiomyopathy for the vet to watch, so ask any breeder about heart screening.