Abyssinian vs American Shorthair

Verdict

Both are medium-sized shorthairs with easy coats, so the choice comes down to energy and company. The Abyssinian scores at the top for energy, play and intelligence, follows its people from room to room and dislikes long stretches alone. The American Shorthair is calmer, more independent and settles into a busy family home without fuss. Choose the Abyssinian for an active partner, and the American Shorthair for a steady, low-maintenance household cat.

Choose the Abyssinian if

• You want a cat that plays hard every day and climbs everything it can reach.
• You enjoy puzzle toys and teaching tricks, since this breed scores highest for intelligence.
• Someone is home for much of the day, because it copes poorly with being alone.
• You want the lightest grooming load, as the fine ticked coat needs very little.

Choose the American Shorthair if

• You want a calm cat that fits a family, with top marks for tolerance of children.
• The home is empty during a workday, since this is the more independent of the two.
• You like a wide choice of colours and patterns, with over 80 recognised.
• You want a durable cat that suits apartment life better than an Abyssinian does.

Where they are alike

Both are common, medium-sized shorthairs with coats that need only occasional brushing. Both get on well with children and with other pets.